Spoiler alert it's not often that I give a book here a perfect 5 rating (especially considering the fact that I can't rate more specifically than in increments of 1) however this was potentially a perfect 5. I thought Cream was quite well done and would love to consider more the idea that Murakami is talking about Dante's 7 circles of hell. On a stone pillow was also absolutely wonderful and quite a hopeless romantic story but I think that there are bits and pieces to take from that regardless. Charlie Parker plays bossa nova started off well but I wish the author had elongated the encounter between the narrator and Charlie Parker - but then again, maybe that's the point of the story and the encounter is intentionally short. With the Beatles was also nice, and I think that if/when I reread it I'd like to read more about the Beatles before. Confessions of a Shinagawa monkey was my favorite story BY FAR and I think that the concept down to the vivid descriptions leaves so much for the reader to want. If there was one story that I would want adapted into visual format it would probably be this one, but at the same time the story was so vivid that I was playing a movie in my head either way. Carnaval was incredibly well done and rekindled a bit of classical music listener in me. I'm not sure what the overarching meaning of the "ugly" motif was but maybe I'll understand it my next time around. On the downside, the Yakult swallows poetry collection was my least favorite. I'd like to think that the interspersed poetry was not the entirety of the reason why, but it just may have been. I also think the baseball imagery was harder to resonate with because I don't know the full background of Japanese baseball. If it was the Yankees, Dodgers, and Red Sox I may have understood the relations and context more, but I think that I was missing something. First person singular (the story) was quite well done but I wish there was a bit more closure towards the end. All in all, this collection was wonderful and leaves me interested in picking up a Murakami book sometime soon - perhaps 1Q84, Kafka on the Shore, or Norwegian Wood.